A claimant company is engaged in High Court litigation against a competitor. During standard disclosure, the claimant's solicitor identifies a memorandum prepared by the claimant's in-house legal counsel advising the board on litigation strategy. The memorandum is located in the files of the claimant's parent company, which is not a party to the proceedings but shares some directors with the claimant. The memorandum is clearly marked 'Privileged and Confidential – Legal Advice'. The defendant requests inspection of all documents listed in the claimant's disclosure list, including the memorandum. The claimant's solicitor lists the memorandum in Part 2 of the disclosure list (documents for which inspection will not be permitted) and claims legal advice privilege. The defendant argues that: (1) the document is in the parent company's control, not the claimant's; and (2) privilege cannot be claimed because the parent company is not a party. Which of the following best describes whether the privilege claim is likely to succeed?
Practise this SQE1 Solicitors Exam Prep question free, then download the PDF, watch the video walkthrough, or unlock timed mock exams for the full web bank.
AThe claim is likely to succeed automatically because the memorandum is marked as privileged, and the court must accept such designations without further inquiry into control or privilege conditions.
BThe claim will fail because the document is not in the claimant's physical possession, and privilege can only be claimed for documents held directly by the party asserting it.
CThe claim will fail because legal advice privilege does not extend to communications involving corporate groups, even where there are shared directors between parent and subsidiary companies.
DThe claim is likely to succeed if the claimant can demonstrate control over the parent company's documents through shared management or authority.
✓ Correct answer: D. The claim is likely to succeed if the claimant can demonstrate control over the parent company's documents through shared management or authority.A party's disclosure obligations extend to documents within its control, which includes documents in the physical possession of another entity if the party has a right to inspect or take copies. Shared directorships and close corporate relationships can establish control. If the claimant can show it has a right to obtain the memorandum from its parent company, the document is disclosable but can be withheld on privilege grounds if it contains legal advice to the client (the claimant or its group). Legal advice privilege protects confidential communications between lawyer and client made for the purpose of giving or receiving legal advice, and can extend to in-house counsel advice. The fact that the document is physically held by a non-party does not defeat privilege if the claimant has control and the privilege conditions are met. The other options incorrectly assume privilege is automatically lost due to the parent company's possession or that privilege cannot be claimed for documents not in direct physical possession.
Keep practising. Use the free SQE1 Solicitors Exam Prep PDF, watch the YouTube walkthrough, or unlock all 10 web questions with timed mock exams.
Free practice here. Timed mocks when you are ready.
Study the SQE1 Solicitors Exam Prep free question explanations, download the PDF, then unlock timed mock exams on the web when you want exam-day practice.
Theory